Event Video--THE FUTURE OF CHARTERS IN MARYLAND

This forum took place on October 15, 2015. After two brief presentations that provided background information on the history, structure and finances involved in charters in Maryland, an audience of charter advocates and those questioning the equity of charters had a chance to have a dialogue. The discussion was moderated by Baltimore Sun Reporter Erica Green.

Blog Post--Grace Lee Boggs

GRACE LEE BOGGS: One of the difficulties when you're coming out of oppression is that you get a concept of the messiah. You have to get to that point that we are the leaders we've been looking for. We are the children of Martin and Malcolm. I don't know what the next American revolution is going to be like, but we might be able to imagine it, if your imagination were rich enough.

Read the full transcript of interview excerpts here.

Workshop--Social Justice Curriculum Writing Workshops

Join Our inquiry-to-action-group (ITAG)

This ITAG is an opportunity for 6-8 teachers to research and implement a social justice unit plan to be published using a peer-review process (similar to the Chicago Grassroots Curriculum). Building on the curriculum planning work begun during the TDP Summer Institute, teachers get together in interest/subject area groups to discuss details of protocols they are using in their classrooms, share student projects, research useful resources, and invite local experts and community leaders to join their discussions. The goal is for teachers to find common ground in their day-to-day classroom work, and to find ways to collaborate more deeply in inter-school projects and organizing efforts. Participants may earn a stipend of up to $500. The whole project will take approximately 45 hours from early October to mid-December. Participants in the TDP Summer Curriculum Workshop have priority for this workshop:

Curriculum Workshop to discuss research, original source documents, readings, and pedagogy Individual planning and preparation of curriculum with peer feedback online Documenting implementation, refining, publishing to share online, at conferences, as school-based PD

Limited space available. Register here.

Group--The Reflective Teacher

Join us for dinner and stories about problems of practice in schools and classrooms. One or two people each month will share their stories and participate in a structured reflection process that provides substantive feedback (on issues such as race and identity), promotes a sense of mutual support, and deepens practice for all participants. Click here to register

Thursdays 5pm -7pm

Dream House, 1430 Carswell St. 

November 5, 2015

SPECIAL EVENTS

Network with other teachers and education advocates as you watch films, listen to panels and discuss ideas on a range of topics of interest to educators and community members.

Click here to register for any of the following dates. 

Thursdays 6pm-8pm  (Locations to be announced)

Oct 15   “Charters: The Illusion of Change” (Register for this event here)

Mar 17   “Teacher Activism in Baltimore”

Apr 21    “Corporatized: The Real Story About the Public Education Takeover”

Jun 9     “School Stories: The Human Face of Policy”

Education Advocacy Follow-Up Session II

July 30

9AM-3PM DREAM HOUSE 1430 CARSWELL ST., 21218

This workshop is an opportunity for 8-10 teachers and education advocates to get focused assistance on their writing skills for the purpose of reflection and advocacy. Participants will engage in peer feedback during the different stages of research and writing and analyze examples of blogs for writing styles and effectiveness of message.

Participants will also do research into specific education reform issues as they apply to Baltimore and help work on building our grassroots education activist network.

Finally, participants will practice interviewing each other to learn interviewing techniques.

TDP Summer Institut Follow Up Sessions Flyer TDP Summer Institut Follow Up Sessions Flyer bck

School Stories: What Just Happened to me? Follow-Up Session II

July 31

12:30pm-2pm Dream House 1430 Carswell St., 21218

Thinking deeply about strange and con ict-ridden incidents in the classroom as a way to develop our re ective practice.

This “story-as-re ection process” using the Critical Response Process is geared toward teachers at any stage of their careers who want to talk over how to use reflection to dig deeper into classroom practice and how our educational values get expressed in the minute-to-minute decisions we make. The goal is mostly to encourage and support each other’s personal reflections on our classrooms for the purpose of improving our practice, getting closer to students, colleagues or communities in order to improve our teaching and connections.

TDP Summer Institut Follow Up Sessions Flyer TDP Summer Institut Follow Up Sessions Flyer bck

The past is never gone Follow-Up Session II

July 24

9am-3pm Dream House 1430 Carswell St., 21218

Develop curriculum that helps students learn, within the con nes of a curricular mandate, how their neighborhoods have been transformed by sytematically racist policies over the years.

This curriculum-focused workshop invites participants to bring the materials, books, sources and ideas they have used to expose students to critical thinking about the history of race and neighborhoods within Baltimore. We will ask questions about how to construct curriculum from both and historical events/policies--curriculum that can be used for di erent age groups and to teach di erent subjects. We will share problems we have encountered with respect to curricular mandates, debate the most salient and engaging events and the messages they provide, share classroom protocols that work to engage all students, and set up an on-going forum for exchanging curriculum plans and doing collaborative eld work on this vital topic.

TDP Summer Institut Follow Up Sessions Flyer TDP Summer Institut Follow Up Sessions Flyer bck

Education Advocacy Follow-Up Session I

July 23

9am-3pm Dream House 1430 Carswell St., 21218

This workshop is an opportunity for 8-10 teachers and education advocates to get focused assistance on their writing skills for the purpose of reflection and advocacy. Participants will engage in peer feedback during the different stages of research and writing and analyze examples of blogs for writing styles and effectiveness of message.

Participants will also do research into specific education reform issues as they apply to Baltimore and help work on building our grassroots education activist network.

Finally, participants will practice interviewing each other to learn interviewing techniques.

TDP Summer Institut Follow Up Sessions Flyer TDP Summer Institut Follow Up Sessions Flyer bck

TDP Op-Ed in Baltimore Sun

Treat neighborhood schools like charters

In the wake of a contentious debate in Annapolis this spring that featured a bill that gives charter school operators more control over their schools (while principal autonomy was rolled back at struggling traditional schools), a show down over supplemental education funding, and a great deal of rhetorical debate around "autonomy," "choice," "accountability" and "successful" schools, we are wondering where the neighborhood schools are left.

Is the implication that teachers and principals in traditional schools are fundamentally different from principals and teachers in higher status schools? Would they fail to rise to the occasion if they were given the same deal that charters have?

See Op-Ed in Baltimore Sun here.

Ask any principal or teacher what they would do if only they had the freedom to follow their beliefs; it's a safe bet they have a plan. Ask any community member who has experienced the vicissitudes of neighborhood institutions over time whether they would support a school where they could help make decisions and share responsibility for the results, and the answer would be a firm "of course."

Why not offer traditional schools and their communities the same autonomy, freedom from onerous constraints, predictability in their funding and ability to make promises that they can keep to current and prospective teachers, children and families?

All of our school communities should have the chance to write the equivalent of a charter application that establishes a community-wide commitment to a belief-based approach to curriculum and pedagogy. What if the schools that muster this support were, as a result, afforded the same per pupil funding as charters and had the ability to select additional services (beyond a reasonable set of services that ensure equity, transparency and legality) to buy from central office? What if all schools could select whether to administer "benchmark" tests in addition to those mandated by the state? What if, based on these fresh chances and fresh sense of control, these schools could attract the most talented principals of their own choosing, who could in turn attract and keep excellent existing and new teachers? Will any superintendent or school board ever be brave and supportive enough to relinquish a portion of their power in service of democratic community control?

The rhetorical argument used by charter advocates is that only charter schools have the capacity to take on what they see as an extra load of accountability. We argue that charter schools in Baltimore are perhaps subject to somewhat less routine scrutiny (process-based accountability) than traditional schools and thus have an unfair edge. To the extent that they are subject to district rules, they serve as proverbial canaries-in-the-mine for the inefficiencies that all schools experience. Charters are among a subset of schools that have privileges not shared by all public schools; to name a few: the ability to select curriculum without restraint; a per pupil funding amount that gives them greater financial control; an ability to carry forward all left-over money at year's end, thus making long-term financial planning a possibility; and an ability to opt out of various district-mandated testing regimes. No one from the central office is making unannounced visits to charter school classrooms to ensure that teachers are on page 57 of lesson 31 on exactly April 22nd. Charter school spending is not frozen arbitrarily in April. They get to select the central office services they want to pay for. One can call these autonomies, or one can call them the reduction of process accountability.

Even the end-point or outcomes-based accountability that charters do deal with every three to five years in the form of a renewal application and a "school effectiveness review" is probably no more onerous and somewhat more predictable than the review process currently faced by many other schools. Non-charter schools face their reviews without the support of an independent operator to run interference between the school and district. Charters are subject to fewer of the unpredictable threats of closure faced by many other schools under No Child Left Behind.

Of course, politically speaking, this is a difficult stance to take. In an era when only few schools are immune from these threats of sanctions, charters — and other high-status public and private schools — are oases of relative predictability and security. Why would they want to give up their edge? People will say it cannot be done. People will say we do not have the talent pool. People will say that communities cannot be trusted.

Let us not make the mistake of thinking that what is good for the charter school goose is not also good for the traditional school gander.

Helen Atkinson is director of the Teachers' Democracy Project and is a former charter operator in Baltimore; democracyproject@icloud.com. Corey Gaber is a 6th grade teacher at a charter school in Baltimore; cbgaber@gmail.com. Ben Dalbey is a parent of two Baltimore city public schools children and an early childhood teacher; bendalbey@yahoo.com.

THE REAL NEWS NETWORK COVERS SCHOOL LOCK-IN

The Real News Network (TRNN)-The Real Baltimore talked with Park Heights residents and supporters about keeping Langston Hughes Elementary School TRNN School Lock Inopen. Director of Teachers' Democracy Project (TDP), Helen Atkinson, was also interviewed and shares her support for LHES highlighting the disparities in the selection of schools slated to close as well as how small schools like LHES are anchors for residents. View the full video and transcript by TRNN here.

Image courtesy of The Real News Network

Protests attempt to bring attention to the racial disparity in school closings in Baltimore

The school board says that Langston Hughes Elementary School (at a total enrollment of 176) is too small, and that: "declines in enrollment make it difficult to support and maintain robust programming."  (Baltimore City School Closure and Relocation Report) In fact, small size has been the only consistent reason given by school system administrators for closing Langston Hughes, a reasonably successful and well-respected school in a struggling, low-income black neighborhood in Northwest Baltimore.  But a quick review of the 10 smallest schools in Baltimore (not including schools for students with disabilities) shows a disturbing pattern.  Four of the 10 smallest schools—the ones that serve almost entirely (over 90%) African American students--are slated for closure.  The four schools that serve a disproportionate percentage (over 40%) of White students (compared with the 15% of white students in the school system) are all staying open.  The same pattern emerges if you broaden the study to include more small schools. The mass rally and lock-in that took place last Friday outside and inside the school was the the sixth action in an on-going battle to save the school.   Neighborhood leaders and local supporters are bringing attention to the fact that this is a good school in a well-maintained building with great support from the community.  They are questioning why the school board would close a good school.  “Langston Hughes is a gem!” says George Mitchell from the Langston Hughes Community Action Association. He points out that the school students will be sent to, if the threat of closure is realized, is Pimlico Elementary/Middle—a school located a mile away, across a major street, and surrounded by a particularly run-down section of the community where abandoned homes, drug dealing, dirt bikes, tall weeds and trash are rampant.  The five previous community protests have all involved adults and children taking the same walk to be taken by students as young as 4 and 5 years old each day.  At recent school board meetings Mr. Mitchell and other community leaders have challenged the school board members to come “do the walk.”  So far they have all declined.  Parents, community members and supporters from other parts of the city who have taken the walk have all been outraged at the prospect of sending students through these streets to a school where there are already rumors of violent threats against the “new kids.”  Pimlico is the worst performing school in the Park Heights community and has issues of over-crowding, poor building conditions, and high teacher turnover.  The school is slated for renovation over the next several years which parents believe will make the overcrowding and health issues even worse.

So local leaders are asking the question: “Why, in a city where all eyes are on the underlying causes of our recent unrest, are we threatening to close a school such as Langston Hughes?”  Why would we close any small, safe and relatively successful school, particularly if it is located in a low income, Black neighborhood and serves as a vital anchor-institution?  If the only reason is that the schools are “too small,” and therefore “inefficient,” how is it that equally small schools serving whiter, more middle class populations get to stay open?  One reason, they believe, is that these whiter, more middle class schools are charter schools and enjoy a relatively protected status and more flexible budget: Montessori Middle (88 enrolled; 42% White; 39% FARMS—Free and Reduced Meals); Independence School Local 1 (127 enrolled; 41% White; 68% FARMS); Green School (150 enrolled; 45% White; 27% FARMS), City Neighbors Charter School (216 enrolled; 43% White; 38% FARMS).  We see small schools that are free from threat of closure and able to provide exactly the kind of programming that makes sense for the families whose children attend them.  Three of these schools serve fewer students than Langston Hughes where attendance been lower in recent years due primarily to the threat of closure and competition from nearby charter schools. A comparison between a small Black school such as Langston Hughes and these other small schools immediately reveals two facts: Small schools are often safer, more caring, and more likely to produce good academic results for children who might otherwise not succeed in a larger setting (such as Pimlico Elementary/Middle)—a fact that appeals equally to low income and middle income parents.  The second fact is that the charter schools receive more of their funding in cash out payments ($9450 for charters compared to approximately $6800 for Langston Hughes when compared line by budget line).  Charter funding allows schools to voluntarily forgo services from central office in order to provide small class sizes and distinctive programming.  The City Schools budget document for school year 2015-2016 includes this note on small schools: “At the school level, below a certain enrollment, it becomes difficult to provide an adequate standard of care, and things like after-school programming or maintaining a school library may be threatened. That’s why, for FY16, City Schools supplemented the budgets of 19 small schools with an additional $2.2 million.” If Langston Hughes were to convert to charter status it would receive approximately $400,000 more than it does now without any additional “subsidy” from the school system.  Leaving aside whether charter schools actually cost the school system more than neighborhood schools, and leaving aside the even more important issue of lack of truly adequate funding for all our city schools, it is undeniable that some parents in mostly White neighborhoods have the option of sending their children to small schools that have the freedom to allocate funds as they see fit to meet their student needs.  Black students from a low-income neighborhood in Northwest Baltimore are being denied this option.

 

Websites and Facebook Pages for more information:

Langston Hughes Community Action Committee https://www.facebook.com/langstonhughescommunityactionassociation?fref=ts

Teachers’ Democracy Project

www.TDPBaltimore.org

Baltimore Algebra Project

www.Baltimorealgebraproject.org

Baltimore City Schools FY16 Budget

http://www.baltimorecityschools.org/cms/lib/MD01001351/Centricity/domain/8052/pdf/FY16-ProposedBudget.pdf

Baltimore City Schools Closure Report

http://www.baltimorecityschools.org/cms/lib/MD01001351/Centricity/Domain/8057/20150226-ClosureRelocationSurplusReport-FINAL.pdf

Summary of “Portfolio Recommendations and Decisions”

http://www.baltimorecityschools.org/Page/27217

 

FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE JUNE 12, 2015

Mass rally and protest to bring attention to the racial disparity in school closings in Baltimore

The school board says that Langston Hughes Elementary School (at a total enrollment of 176) is too small, and that: "declines in enrollment make it difficult to support and maintain robust programming."  (Baltimore City School Closure and Relocation Report) In fact, small size has been the only consistent reason given by school system administrators for closing Langston Hughes, a reasonably successful and well-respected school in a struggling, low-income black neighborhood in Northwest Baltimore.  But a quick review of the 10 smallest schools in Baltimore (not including schools for students with disabilities) shows a disturbing pattern.  Four of the 10 smallest schools—the ones that serve almost entirely (over 90%) African American students--are slated for closure.  The four smallest schools that serve a disproportionate percentage (over 40%) of White students (compared with the 15% of white students in the school system) are all staying open.  The same pattern emerges if you broaden the study to include more small schools.

There is a community meeting at 5:30 pm at Langston Hughes Elementary School tonight to discuss what to do.  The mass rally at7:00 pm outside the school following the community meeting will be the sixth action in an on-going battle to save the school.  Neighborhood leaders and local supporters are bringing attention to the fact that this is a good school in a well-maintained building with great support from the community.  They are questioning why the school board would close a good school.  “Langston Hughes is a gem!” says George Mitchell from the Langston Hughes Community Action Association. He points out that the school students will be sent to, if the threat of closure is realized, is Pimlico Elementary/Middle—a school located a mile away, across a major street, and surrounded by a particularly run-down section of the community where abandoned homes, drug dealing, dirt bikes, tall weeds and trash are rampant.  The five previous community protests have all involved adults and children taking the same walk to be taken by students as young as 4 and 5 years old each day.  At recent school board meetings Mr. Mitchell and other community leaders have challenged the school board members to come “do the walk.” So far they have all declined.  Parents, community members and supporters from other parts of the city who have taken the walk have all been outraged at the prospect of sending students through these streets to a school where there are already rumors of violent threats against the “new kids.”  Pimlico is the worst performing school in the Park Heights community and has issues of over-crowding, poor building conditions, and high teacher turnover.  The school is slated for renovation over the next several years which parents believe will make the overcrowding and health issues even worse.

So local leaders are asking the question: “Why, in a city where all eyes are on the underlying causes of our recent unrest, are we threatening to close a school such as Langston Hughes?”  Why would we close any small, safe and relatively successful school, particularly if it is located in a low income, Black neighborhood and serves as a vital anchor-institution?  If the only reason is that the schools are “too small,” and therefore “inefficient,” how is it that equally small schools serving whiter, more middle class populations get to stay open?  One reason, they believe, is that these whiter, more middle class schools are charter schools and enjoy a relatively protected status and more flexible budget: Montessori Middle (88 enrolled; 42% White; 39% FARMS—Free and Reduced Meals); Independence School Local 1 (127 enrolled; 41% White; 68% FARMS); Green School (150 enrolled; 45% White; 27% FARMS), City Neighbors Charter School (216 enrolled; 43% White; 38% FARMS).  We see small schools that are free from threat of closure and able to provide exactly the kind of programming that makes sense for the families whose children attend them.  Three of these schools serve fewer students than Langston Hughes where attendance been lower in recent years due primarily to the threat of closure and competition from nearby charter schools. A comparison between a small Black school such as Langston Hughes and these other three schools immediately reveals two facts: Small schools are often safer, more caring, and more likely to produce good academic results for children who might otherwise not succeed in a larger setting (such as Pimlico Elementary/Middle)—a fact that appeals equally to low income and middle income parents. The second fact is that the charter schools receive more of their funding in cash out payments ($9450 for charters compared to approximately $6800 for Langston Hughes when compared line by budget line).  Charter funding allows schools to voluntarily forgo services from central office in order to provide small class sizes and distinctive programming.  The City Schools budget document for school year 2015-2016 includes this note on small schools: “At the school level, below a certain enrollment, it becomes difficult to provide an adequate standard of care, and things like after-school programming or maintaining a school library may be threatened. That’s why, for FY16, City Schools supplemented the budgets of 19 small schools with an additional $2.2 million.” If Langston Hughes were to convert to charter status it would receive approximately $400,000 more than it does now without any additional “subsidy” from the school system.  Leaving aside whether charter schools actually cost the school system more than neighborhood schools, it is undeniable that some parents in mostly White neighborhoods have the option of sending their children to small schools that have the freedom to allocate funds as they see fit to meet their student needs.  Black students from a low-income neighborhood in Northwest Baltimore are being denied this option.

Contact information:

George Mitchell        gem14gem14@gmail.com            240-463-0195

Helen Atkinson         hatkinson333@gmail.com             443-813-0936

Jamal Jones             jamal.jones76@yahoo.com           410-446-7942

Charnell Covert Cobb-el    ccobbel@baltimorealgebraproject.org 443-928-5893

Websites and Facebook Pages for more information:

Langston Hughes Community Action Committeehttps://www.facebook.com/langstonhughescommunityactionassociation?fref=ts

Teachers’ Democracy Project

www.TDPBaltimore.org

Baltimore Algebra Project

www.Baltimorealgebraproject.org

Baltimore City Schools FY16 Budget

http://www.baltimorecityschools.org/cms/lib/MD01001351/Centricity/domain/8052/pdf/FY16-ProposedBudget.pdf

Baltimore City Schools Closure Report

http://www.baltimorecityschools.org/cms/lib/MD01001351/Centricity/Domain/8057/20150226-ClosureRelocationSurplusReport-FINAL.pdf

Summary of “Portfolio Recommendations and Decisions”

http://www.baltimorecityschools.org/Page/27217

Occupying Schools

As efforts to keep Langston Hughes Elementary school open to its 180 pupils continue, we find inspiration in seeing how other communities took matters into their own hands to keep their schools from closing. The following articles are an example of how parents, teachers, and education advocates joined forces to push against efforts to displace students, staff, and teachers. Be Inspired!

image
Chicago Parents Occupy School | Teacher Solidarity

Parents in Chicago have occupied a school which is threatened with takeoverThe Piccolo Elementary School in Chicago is threatened with 'turnaround' and takeover by ...
Preview by Yahoo
image
Chicago Teachers Union | Piccolo Elem. Parents Occupy A...

The Chicago Teachers Union is an organization of educators dedicated to advancing and promoting quality public education, improving teaching and learning condit...
Preview by Yahoo
image
Parents, Teachers 'Occupy' Oakland School To Protest Clo...

One man was proud to be there with his wife and three children - sleeping in tents on the school courtyard for the past few days.
Preview by Yahoo
Parents occupy Oakland school to protest closures » peoplesworld

OAKLAND, Calif. - Despite the Oakland Unified School District's order that they leave the premises, parents and teachers occupying Lakeview Elementary School since June 15 say they plan to stay until the district agrees to keep their school and four others open, reversing its deci...
Preview by Yahoo
Parents, Students Occupy Lafayette School (UPDATED) | Progress Illinois

Parents and students are occupying Lafayette Elementary school this afternoon in protest of the school's closing.
Preview by Yahoo
image
WATCH: Parents Occupy Closing School In Protest

The last bell was set to ring at Chicago's Lafayette Elementary School in Humboldt Park Wednesday afternoon, but Lafayette parents had other plans in mind. Around ...
Preview by Yahoo
Parents, Students Occupy Lafayette Elementary Classroom On School's Last Day (VIDEO) | Progress ...

Just after final classes let out at Jean D. Lafayette Elementary Wednesday, three parents and their children occupied a classroom for hours in opposition of the Chicago Public Schools' (CPS) plan to close the school for good this month.
Preview by Yahoo
image
Parents Occupy Classroom To Protest School Closings

Parents took over a classroom at Lafayette Elementary to protest the city's plan to shut down the school after this year.
Preview by Yahoo

WHAT JUST HAPPENED TO ME?

June 29

9pm-3pm, dream house 1430 carswell street, 21218

Thinking deeply about strange and conflict-ridden incidents in the classroom as a way to develop our reflective practice.

This story-as-reflection workshop is geared toward teachers at any stage of their careers who want to talk over how to use reflection to dig deeper into who we are in the classroom, and how our educational values get expressed in the minute-to-minute decisions we make. The goal is mostly to encourage and support each other’s personal reflections on our classrooms for the purpose of improving our practice, getting closer to students, and finding a perspective with which to deal with stuff that just doesn’t make sense. There is the option for participants to keep meeting during the summer and school year. A set of readings and reflection guidelines will be provided, but participants are also encouraged to contribute their own materials to share with others.

TDP Summer Institut Flyer TDP Summer Institut Flyer back

Register here!

EDUCATION ADVOCACY

July 1

9AM-3PM, DREAM HOUSE 1430 CARSWELL STREET, 21218

Telling school and neighborhood stories in writing and in video so other people will read/view them and so you won’t get fired.

In this story workshop we will all practice writing stories and doing short audio or video recordings to capture stories about schools and neighborhoods and about the relationship between them. The purpose is to improve our own storytelling abilities, to learn more about how to ethically and safely elicit stories from other people, and how to “publish” our stories. TDP, in conjunction with other partners, will continue gathering stories (in writing, audio and video) over the summer. We will discuss how the recording of a collection of individual stories can lead to the formation a larger counter-narrative about a school wide, systemic or neighborhood issue.

This larger narrative is controlled by the people telling the stories and can serve to replace the accepted narrative about educational failure with dreams about the schools and neighborhoods we deserve. This workshop will discuss how to collect the stories, build a team and instigate massive yet focused change.

 Register here!

TDP Summer Institut FlyerTDP Summer Institut Flyer back

Video Workshop: How to Make Videos in Your Classroom

august 4&6

9am-3pm, dream house 1430 Carswell street, 21218

This two-day intensive workshop led by Wide Angle Media www.wideanglemedia.org will provide teachers and other TDP associates with the skills to make their own videos either with students in their classrooms, or with other education activists. We use iPads and other classroom-friendly equipment and learn editing tricks on iMovie. This equipment can be borrowed from TDP for classroom projects during the school year.

Space for this valuable workshop is limited, so register early!!!

TDP FILM WORKSHOP FLYER